Windmoeller
Published

Get Smarter on Extruder Sizes

Extrusion Know How

Processors tend to recommend a much larger extruder than what’s really necessary for the job and the capabilities of the downstream equipment.

Share

Knowing that customer requirements change continuously and output improvements are always being pursued, operating people nowadays tend to recommend a much larger extruder than what’s really necessary for the job and the capabilities of the downstream equipment. While getting an oversized extruder provides “just-in-case” flexibility, it can also result in much higher daily operating costs. Let’s take a look at why.

Both AC and DC drives have a higher power usage per pound of output at low speeds. DC drives are even more expensive to operate than AC drives at low speeds because of their additional disadvantage of poor power factor at low speed. The larger extruder increases thermal losses to the environment because the latter are proportional to the heated surface area of the extruder. This can be useful in cold weather to heat the plant, but it is a major cost factor in warm weather, particularly if it requires use of air conditioning.

The electrical requirements for heat-up and temperature maintenance are also proportional to the extruder’s mass. Heat-up time can double from one extruder size to the next. Although not usually a major cost factor, larger extruders also require more floor space. More importantly, they also require larger-capacity utilities with higher expenses associated with installation and maintenance.

Another important cost factor is the extra time it takes to start up and change over a larger extruder. This extra time results in lost production and generation of larger amounts of scrap. Even routine changeovers requiring purging are more expensive, as much more purge material is required to change materials or colors.

Naturally the capital investment expense goes up with machine size, and that has to be amortized into the production cost. Moving up one extruder size roughly doubles the installed capital investment. At equivalent outputs, larger extruders have more residence time and have more material inside, increasing the likelihood of degradation as well as the amount of degraded polymer.

Simply put, extruder size needs to be considered in the daily economics of producing extruded products. For example, operating a 4.5-in. extruder at 1000 lb/hr and a 6-in. extruder at the same output can result in a 50-100% increase in total operating cost, depending on the particulars of the equipment, electrical cost, number of changeovers, and polymers being processed.

Deciding on the right extruder size is also important when deploying the extruders you already have in place. Many times, I have seen little or no thought going into the selection of the most economical extruder. Recently I  saw thin-gauge, narrow PET sheet being run on a 6-in., 34:1 extruder with a 500-hp drive. The screw speed was 36 rpm with a maximum of 125 rpm. Sitting nearby was an older 4.5-in, 30:1 extruder with 200 hp that would have done fine. But the processor preferred the new line because it was easier to operate. Here the hourly operating cost was approximately twice what it could/should have been.

Picking the right size extruder is pretty much a function of the output at a reasonable screw speed. The proper L/D ratio depends on the requirements for mixing, venting, and pressure generation. Horsepower is a function of output and the polymer being processed and can be easily calculated. However, this can be a rather complex matrix of choices, and decisions should be left to experts. 

My advice is to develop an hourly operating cost for each extrusion line and try to fit production to the least expensive line as a part of the scheduling procedure.

Shuttle Mold System
Vacuum conveying powders to extruders compounding
Uway LLC
Cranes, Conveyors, Racks, Loaders, Accessories
Plastics Recycling Latam
Vecoplan
Konica Minolta CM-36dG
Guill - World Leader in Extrusion Tooling
Windmoeller
Maguire Ultra
mold, mould track, digital tracking, molding
NPE2024: The Plastics Show

Related Content

sustainability

Sustainability Among the Many Niches at Niche Polymer

Founded in 1987, Niche Polymer continues to grow—both organically and through acquisition—by focusing its product-development efforts on ever-changing market needs. Adding value to both industrial and post-consumer scrap is a growing part of this effort.  

Read More
best practices

How to Configure Your Twin-Screw Extruder: Part 3

The melting mechanism in a twin-screw extruder is quite different from that of a single screw. Design of the melting section affects how the material is melted, as well as melt temperature and quality.

Read More
Compounding

How to Maintain Pelletizing Quality When Acid Attacks

Developments in the chemistry of polymers and additives have made corrosion a real problem in pelletizers. Here’s how to ward it off.  

Read More
Compounding

Green’s the Theme in Extrusion/Compounding

The drive toward circular economy is requiring processors to make more use of PCR. Machine builders at K—across all extrusion processes—will be highlighting innovations to help them do just that.

Read More

Read Next

sustainability

Advanced Recycling: Beyond Pyrolysis

Consumer-product brand owners increasingly see advanced chemical recycling as a necessary complement to mechanical recycling if they are to meet ambitious goals for a circular economy in the next decade. Dozens of technology providers are developing new technologies to overcome the limitations of existing pyrolysis methods and to commercialize various alternative approaches to chemical recycling of plastics.

Read More
Extrusion Know How

How Polymer Melts in Single-Screw Extruders

Understanding how polymer melts in a single-screw extruder could help you optimize your screw design to eliminate defect-causing solid polymer fragments.  

Read More
Realationships