Click Image to Enlarge
Wedging results in a burr on the trailing side of the flight (Fig. 1). Misalignment produces a burr on both the trailing and leading edges of the flight (Fig. 2) due to the crushing and frictional effects.
Two of the more catastrophic causes of flight wear on single screws are wedging and misalignment. They are often mistaken for one another when inspecting the screw. Here’s how to diagnose the problem correctly.
Wedging results from inadequate melting, which causes a short section of the screw channel to intermittently fill completely with unmelted polymer. This creates an unbalanced radial pressure that forces the screw aggressively against the barrel in the opposite direction. This occurs almost exclusively in the compression area of the screw, where the channel volume is being reduced. This has been covered in more detail in previous columns (Feb. ’12 and May ’13).
Wear resulting from bending or misalignment can occur anywhere on the screw and is caused by the screw bending while rotating to conform to a barrel bore. Remember barrels are typically many times stronger than the screw because of their higher moment of inertia, so the screw will bend to conform to it. I have also covered alignment in another column (Dec. ’09).
Wedging and misalignment create different forces and wear patterns on the screw. These should provide some clues as to what’s causing the wear because the screw will look different, depending on whether wedging or misalignment is the culprit. In both instances the screw will show galling.
Galling is “a form of wear caused by adhesion between sliding surfaces. When a material galls, some of it is pulled with the contacting surface, especially if there is a large amount of force compressing the surfaces together. Galling is caused by a combination of friction and adhesion between the surfaces, followed by slipping and tearing of crystal structure beneath the surface. This will generally leave some material stuck or even friction welded to the adjacent surface, whereas the galled material may appear gouged with balled-up or torn lumps of material stuck to its surface.” (Wikipedia.com).
When wedging or screw misalignment occurs, the high compressive forces on the flight squeeze out any polymer that normally lubricates the two surfaces. Wedging creates a localized sliding friction with a very high normal force. This force can persist for at least a partial revolution until the wedge breaks up by melting and/or pressure, depending on the conditions of the wedging. Because the flight has an angle to the circumferential direction of the sliding friction, it drags some of the flight material off the back or trailing side of the flight.
If, on inspection, you see crushed flights, a misaligned barrel is likely the reason. A screw that’s conformed to the bent barrel experiences a larger direct and opposing compressive force on its flights, depending on the degree of misalignment. That force tends to crush the flight as the screw is forced to conform to essentially a reduced bore caused by the misalignment. The crushing force—when coupled with the same high frictional force as in wedging—causes very rapid wear.
While wedging results in a “burr” on the trailing side of the flight (see Fig. 1), misalignment produces a burr on both the trailing and leading edges of the flight due to the crushing and frictional effects (Fig. 2). In either case, the flight material is being displaced by the flow of the metal due to the pressure and/or adhesion between the screw flight and barrel wall. The best choice of material for the screw flights is usually determined by a combination of its tendency to resist galling under high loads and its hardness.
Although both wedging and misalignment cause rapid wear, misalignment often is more catastrophic because of the combined effects of adhesive wear and crushing. In hundreds of screw inspections the tell-tale burrs have been helpful in determining the cause of the wear and the solution. It’s not unusual to have both types of wear but in different parts of the screw. As noted, wedging occurs almost exclusively in the compression section of the screw or in highly restrictive mixers that become plugged with unmelt. On the other hand, misalignment can occur anywhere along the screw.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR: JIM FRANKLAND
Jim Frankland is a mechanical engineer who has been involved in all types of extrusion processing for more than 40 years. He is now president of Frankland Plastics Consulting, LLC. Contact email@example.com or (724)651-9196.