The geometry of the screw makes shear heating hard to understand. Envision a flightless shaft turning in a tube. Visualize a very viscous fluid filling the space between the shaft and tube, and a slight bit of pressure at the right end. Since this imaginary material is very viscous it will take take a lot of work to turn the shaft. The slight pressure moves the viscous fluid from right to left.
The work by the shaft is converted to heat in the viscous fluid, known as viscous dissipation. The same thing happens with melted polymer in an actual extruder. The melt continues being heated by the rotation of the screw for as long as it remains in the barrel. The heat either stays in the polymer until it exits the extruder, or is removed from the system by passing through the barrel and cooling system.
It’s hard to cool polymers because they are poor conductors of heat. Polymers are, in fact, excellent insulators—their heat-transfer rate is less than 1% of that of steel.
Meanwhile, the rotation of the screw is adding heat continuously to the melt, offsetting what is extracted. Minor changes in barrel temperature have a very small effect on the overall withdrawal of heat from the system. As screw speed is increased, addition of heat from viscous dissipation usually overrides the ability of the cooling system to absorb heat, and the melt temperature continues to increase even with maximum cooling being applied.
Screw size is a factor as well. As screw size increases, the amount of polymer vs. the surface area of the barrel increases exponentially, so the effectiveness of barrel cooling is reduced.
Fortunately runaway temperatures are not the norm because polymer viscosity is decreased by both increasing temperature and shear rate (screw speed). As a result, most extrusion processes operate in a relatively narrow range of melt temperatures for a given polymer. That said, different polymers have different sensitivities to either shear rate or temperature.
Polymers can be described by the power-law coefficient, which is a simple relationship derived from the shear-rate/viscosity curves at different temperatures. It describes the viscosity in most of the processing range of the extruder.
Polymers have a consistency index (m) and a power-law coefficient (n) that describe its general viscosity behavior with respect to changing temperature (T) and shear rate (Ÿ). The consistency index is primarily the relationship between the polymer’s viscosity and temperature. Although useful in extrapolating the viscosity for design calculations, the consistency index is somewhat considered a dependent variable.
The power-law coefficient, however, has significant effect on heat generation, which in turn impacts the final temperature and resultant viscosity. This is important to understanding what can be expected for a polymer’s final melt temperature using a particular screw design. Polymers that have lower power-law coefficients will see a greater change in viscosity with changing shear. As the viscosity drops, the amount of energy required to rotate that portion of the screw will decrease and additional heat generated from the screw will be reduced. The accompanying table shows the consistency index and power-law coefficient for several polymer types, and the temperature range in which the values were established.
HDPE, for example, would be expected to reduce its viscosity by a factor of three compared with the viscosity reduction for nylon 66 over the same change in shear rate or screw speed. This means that the additional shear heating of HDPE would be less than for nylon 66 as screw speed increases.
By referring to the power-law coefficient, the effect of barrel override in the metering section of many screws can be explained and anticipated. Polymers with a high power-law coefficient would likely generate more heat in the melt with increasing shear rate through viscous dissipation. This adds another complexity to optimum extruder selection, wherein the ideal L/D can be influenced by the polymer’s power-law coefficient. In general, polymers with high power-law coefficients should be processed at lower screw speeds and on shorter L/D screws than those with low coefficients.
Editor PickSuppliers Team to Run Precision Teflon Tubing at Medical Show
Apart from the triennial K Show, extrusion system suppliers don’t operate lines at trade fairs that much anymore.