Make Every Pellet Count
Published

Legal Resource Discusses Proposed Plastics Bill

U.S. Senator Tom Udall (D-N.M.) and U.S. Representative Alan Lowenthal (D-Calif.) announced that they plan to introduce legislation this fall that will tackle the plastic waste crisis. Maureen Gorsen, partner in Alston & Bird's Environment, Land Use & Natural Resources Group, talks about the potential impact of the plan.  

Share

This fall, U.S. Senator Tom Udall (D-N.M.) and U.S. Representative Alan Lowenthal (D-Calif.) plan to introduce legislation that aims to address plastic waste. The proposal includes a mix of phase-outs of certain single-use consumer products, an extended producer responsibility for those and other products, and deposit or charge requirements at the consumer retail level. Companies that produce products would be required to design, manage and finance end-of-life programs for both products and their packaging. 

Maureen Gorsen is a partner in Alston & Bird's Environment, Land Use & Natural Resources Group and a national chemicals authority who has testified previously before Congress on proposed reforms. She’s also the former director of the California Department of Toxic Substances Control and former general counsel of the California Environmental Protection Agency. Here’s her perspective on the potential impact of this plan:

What are some of the key components of this proposed legislation for producers?

The proposal is almost a kitchen sink of all the Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) bills and concepts that have been floating around, tested or enacted in smaller components in many localities and states. So, it has many components. The principle component is the very idea of EPR, which is that design of and material choices for products and packaging should take into account the end-of-life disposal costs at the front end, and that the manufacturer bear those costs—not local governments or the public. 

To that end, the main part of the proposal would require manufacturers of plastic products and packaging design to manage and finance for the end-of-life management prior to the time of sale.

The proposal would also put a national deposit on beverage containers at the retail level, require beverage sellers to install reverse vending machines, place fees on all non-reusable carryout bags—paper and plastic—set recycling targets to get to 100% recyclability, add labels on plastic consumer products to indicate presence of plastic and proper disposal and ban lightweight plastic carryout bags, cups, lids, cotton buds, cutlery, plates, straws, snack packaging and drink stirrers as well as expanded polystyrene in foodware, disposable coolers and shipping packaging.

In addition, the proposed federal bill would set collection targets for states for single-use plastic drink bottles and penalize states that hinder local governments from taking even more aggressive measures with a loss of federal funding.

What is the potential impact of this legislation for those in the plastics manufacturing industry who produce plastic packaging?

There is already a push in states such as California to eliminate all single-use plastic packaging, so we will see a reduction in demand with this proposal even if it does not pass, as other states will pick up on and enact some of its key components. R&D costs will go up to redesign the materials to meet new recyclability standards, and the requirement to incorporate the costs of disposal will increase their price and make them less desirable in the marketplace.

 What type of impact will this have on the cost of consumer products? 

This will result in shifts in choices in material choices across industries, so it is too broad a question to have a single answer. Some products will be more expensive, but some material changes may be cost- neutral or have significant savings as consumers get used to having less packaging overall.

Do you see the potential for brands to shift from plastic packaging to other packaging material to avoid having to cover the costs such as waste management and clean-up?

Absolutely, I haven’t seen a plastic straw in a while. They’ve all been replaced with paper straws. This will happen in many plastic products and packaging sectors.

Vacuum conveying powders to extruders compounding
RoyAlloy Stainless Mold Base Steel
Uway LLC
New Tinius Olsen VectorExtensometer testing
Create custom Smartflow assemblies on-line, 24/7.
Dover Clear
Blending Revolution
Vecoplan
NPE2024: The Plastics Show
Dri-Air
Shuttle Mold System
AM Workshop

Related Content

sustainability

How to Optimize Injection Molding of PHA and PHA/PLA Blends

Here are processing guidelines aimed at both getting the PHA resin into the process without degrading it, and reducing residence time at melt temperatures.

Read More
Postindustrial

Avoid Four Common Traps In Granulation

Today, more than ever, granulation is an important step in the total production process. Our expert explains a few of the many common traps to avoid when thinking about granulators

Read More
Additives

Resins & Additives for Sustainability in Vehicles, Electronics, Packaging & Medical

Material suppliers have been stepping up with resins and additives for the ‘circular economy,’ ranging from mechanically or chemically recycled to biobased content.  

Read More
Recycling

Advanced Recycling: Beyond Pyrolysis

Consumer-product brand owners increasingly see advanced chemical recycling as a necessary complement to mechanical recycling if they are to meet ambitious goals for a circular economy in the next decade. Dozens of technology providers are developing new technologies to overcome the limitations of existing pyrolysis methods and to commercialize various alternative approaches to chemical recycling of plastics.

Read More

Read Next

sustainability

Advanced Recycling: Beyond Pyrolysis

Consumer-product brand owners increasingly see advanced chemical recycling as a necessary complement to mechanical recycling if they are to meet ambitious goals for a circular economy in the next decade. Dozens of technology providers are developing new technologies to overcome the limitations of existing pyrolysis methods and to commercialize various alternative approaches to chemical recycling of plastics.

Read More
industry 4.0

People 4.0 – How to Get Buy-In from Your Staff for Industry 4.0 Systems

Implementing a production monitoring system as the foundation of a ‘smart factory’ is about integrating people with new technology as much as it is about integrating machines and computers. Here are tips from a company that has gone through the process.

Read More
Insert and MedTech molding automation solutions